Wednesday, 21 January 2015

Ch 6: The Last Word on Evil: The Second Horseman

"And out came another horse, bright red.  Its rider was permitted to take peace from the earth so that people should slay one another, and he was given a great sword."  Rev 6:4

I attend an Anabaptist church.   Its foundation is built upon Christ-like response to individuals,  to the community and to the world.  There is no justification for violence of any kind, says the Church.  There is no  such concept as Just War.  I am not quite there yet.

John L. asked us to consider Augustine's "Just War" argument. Here are Augustine's Principles of Just War and a Catholic apologetic

My natural self wants to accept the Just War Doctrine.   Surely there must be times when we can ignore Jesus' command not to resist evil.  Yet, an Anabaptist, or any Christian pacifist, would say that no Christian should act violently against another person.

At the same time a Christian pacifist might say  that governments are God-ordained institutions.   God created it for a purpose, knowing that it  would promote evil and violence from time to time.   Government will do violent things.  Let the government do the violent things. (It is likely true that all governments tend to be despotic).    Let Christians not participate in violent activity.

Such a position taken by certain Anabaptists could be seen as hypocritical.  The anabaptist will avoid violence and at the same time enjoy the protection of a violent government.  Indeed, I have heard it said that one cannot be a Christian and also be a politician, for inevitably a politician must make a decision whether the country should go to war.

Here is how I rationalize the dilemma.

At the personal level I understand that I am not to act violently and must not resist evil, in a physical sense at least.  How would I react in defence of my family?  I pray that such a question will remain a hypothetical one.

God has indeed ordained the institution of government.   In a democratic state we have delegated up to Government -- the Chief Magistrate -- the authority to intervene on our behalf in order to limit violence and to deal with the violent.  In this way, the citizen does not have to and should be proscribed from committing violent acts against his or her fellow citizen.

Further, the Chief Magistrate is vested with the responsibility of ensuring that the State is stable, so that the citizenry be not at risk, nor be it unruly.  There are times when the Chief Magistrate will determine that it must go to war.

It is my preference that the Government be populated by Christians who will wrestle with  the awesome responsibility of waging Just War.   I do not agree that Christians should not participate in parliament, join police forces, or volunteer to defend the citizenry.    If we are going to commit the sin of violence,  I prefer that thoughtful peace loving Godly persons who know what Jesus thinks of evil would make those terrible decisions and play those difficult roles.

This matter is so complex and weighty that I cannot develop arguments for or against Just War any more than that written above.  So, I will leave it at that and look forward to your responses.






No comments:

Post a Comment